The concept of disciplined sanctions in Iraqi and Lebanese law (A comparative study)

Main Article Content

Ghassan ALwan Khudair

Abstract

It is know that the administration cannot work without the expressed Human will since then, legislation has paid great attention has paid great attention to the public employee and his legal situation perhaps the most important concern, of the public employee in this regard is the provision of job guaranteess, in cluding the quarantees associated with disciplinary Among its effect, the iraqi legislator was distinuished in this regard by providing a number of means trough wich the employee can get vid of disciplinary pen at ties and avoid their effect, in addition to the judicial methed represented by the obligatory grievance, the iraqi legislator adopted asystem of thanks and appreciation that removes the penalty, but com parative laws, in cluding lebanen remove this penalty trough the aspect of appeal before the state shura council, this letter has therefore produced many result and proposals that would avoid deficiencies in compartive Iraqi legislation

Article Details

How to Cite
ALwan Khudair غ. (2024). The concept of disciplined sanctions in Iraqi and Lebanese law (A comparative study). MIsan Journal of Comparative Legal Studies, 1(10), 483–513. Retrieved from https://uomisan.edu.iq/law/mjcls/index.php/mjcls/article/view/314
Section
Articles

References

أولاً : المؤلفات:

Badir , Ali Muhammad , principles and provisions of administrative law , 1 st ed , Cairo , AL-Atak publications for the Book industry , 2011.

Dr. Essam Abdel Wahab Ebarzanji , principles of administrative law , 1 st ed , Cairo , AL-Atak publications for the Book industry , 2011.

Dr. Najeeb Khalaf Ahmed AL-jubouri , Administrativel law Yadkar Publications , 2014.

Dr. Mahdi Yassin AL-Salami , Principles and provisions of administrative law library , 2011.

Amer Ibrahim Ahmed AL-Shammari , Custibated sanctions in Iraq , Comparative study . 1 Beirut , 2009.

Dr. Ibrahim Abdel Alziz Shiha , Mediator in the provsions of administrative law , Beirut , 1997.

Dr. Adel Talib , Mediator in the civil service , 1 , Baghdad , 2016.

Dr. Ramadan Nasser Taha , The erosion of the disciplinary penalty imposed on public information in Iraq , Comparative study , First edition , Baghdad , Legal Books , 2015.

Dr. Osman Gilan Aboudi , The Tadic for the State officer , 1 , Baghdad . 2012.

Foz Farhat , General Administrative Law , 2 , Halabi , rights publicatios , 2012.

Abdul Latif Qutish , System of text and application , Beirut , 1 , Human rights publications , 2013.

Mohiuddin al-Qaisi , Principles of public Administrative Law , Beirut , Legal Halabi Publications , 2003.

Muhammad Mudar Yahya AL-Bazzaz , Disciplinary penalties in public office , Maysan University Journal of Legal Studies , The eighth issue Volume 1 , p. 402.

Dr. Ghazi Faisal Mahdi , Explain the provisions of the discipline of state employees and the public sector , Baghdad , Den , 2006.

Lawyer Maurice Palm , the broker in explaining staff law , 1 , Beirut Legal Halabi Publications , 2003.

ثانياً : القرارات:

أ‌- القرارات العراقية

Iraqi GeneraL Disciplihe conncil Resolution no , 62/75 , dated 9/1/1967.

Resolution of the Iraqi state shura conncil no. 40 dated 6/5/2007.

Resolution of the Iraqi State Shura Council no. 196 dated 6/6/2014

Decision of the Iraqi civil serrants Judicial court no. 583 dated 6/7/2015

Decision of the Iraqi civil serrants court no. 653. 2015.

Resolution no. 1785 Judiciary of employees , Excellence 2015 dated 11/8/2018.

ب– القرارات اللبنانية:

Resolntion of the Lebanesestate shura coocil no. 442 20/11/1969.

Resolntion of the Lebanese state shurc. 433 dated 3/42001.

سابعاً: المراسيم الاشتراعية:

Lebanese Legislative Decree 112 of 1959 regarding employee regulation.

ثالثاً : القوانين:

Law no. 54 of 1965.

Lebanese penal code no. 340 dated 1/3/1943.

Iraqi unified Retirement Law no. 9 of 2014.

Iraqi Governorates Law no. 21 of 2008.

State Employees Disciptine Law no. 14 of 1991.

State Employees Discipline Law data 69 years 1936 (concel).