The effect of the impossibility of implementation in administrative court rulings (a Comparative Study)

Main Article Content

Wisam Mohammed arhamai
Alaa Nafeh Kataf

Abstract

The issue of the impact of the impossibility of enforcing administrative court rulings is one of the topics that has raised numerous problems that require further consideration. Impossibility is an obstacle to the implementation of rulings، and individuals resort to the judiciary، which is the refuge to which individuals turn to obtain their rights. However، the intended benefit of a ruling does not end with the mere establishment of a right، but rather with the attainment of that right. For this reason، our research addressed impossibility، its types، and the effects that result from the impossibility of enforcing a ruling. The research was based on the significant impact of impossibility on the rights acquired from rulings، on the one hand، and the validity of the rulings، on the other. The best way to implement rulings is through proactive efforts by the administration and its attempts to find solutions، as the administration is closest to the executive process and its responsibility. This stems from a sense of responsibility and the continuity of service provision. Therefore، there is a need for the presence of a committee or executive judge from the administrative judiciary who is responsible for implementing and following up on the rulings issued by it

Article Details

How to Cite
Mohammed arhamai و. ., & Nafeh Kataf ع. . (2026). The effect of the impossibility of implementation in administrative court rulings (a Comparative Study). MIsan Journal of Comparative Legal Studies, 14(1-1), 79–100. Retrieved from https://uomisan.edu.iq/law/mjcls/index.php/mjcls/article/view/508
Section
Articles

References

First: Linguistic Dictionaries

Jamal al-Din Ibn Manzur, Lisan al-Arab, First Edition, Vol. 13, Dar Sahib, Cairo, 2003.

Jamal al-Din Ibn Manzur, Lisan al-Arab, Lisan al-Arab, First Edition, Vol. 13, Dar Sahib, Cairo, 2003.

Shawki Dayf, Al-Mu'jam al-Waseet, Fourth Edition, Arabic Language Academy, Al-Shorouk International Library, Cairo, 2004.

Zain al-Din Abu Abdullah al-Razi, Mukhtar al-Sihah, Second Edition, Vol. 1, Maktabat Lubnan, Beirut, 1995.

Second: Books

Abdul Aziz Abdel Moneim Khalifa, Controls for the Validity of Issuing Administrative Rulings and Appealing Them, no edition, Mansaa Al-Maaref, Alexandria, 2016.

Abdul Ghani Bassiouni, The Principle of Equality Before the Judiciary and Guaranteeing the Right to Litigation - A Comparative Study, Second Edition, Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Beirut, 2001.

Daoud Abdel Razzaq El-Baz, The Principle of Legitimacy and the Judiciary of Administrative Liability, First Edition, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami'i, Alexandria, 2016.

Diana Kamal Ali, Guarantees for the Implementation of Administrative Rulings Against the Administration, First Edition, Dar Walid for Publishing, Distribution, and Software, Cairo, 2022.

Joseph Emile Rizkallah, General Theories of Evidence Before Administrative Courts, First Edition, Sader Legal Publications, Beirut 2010.

Mahmoud Saad Abdel Majeed, Refraining from Executing Judicial Rulings and Using Official Power to Obstruct Their Implementation: Crime and Liability, no edition, Dar Al-Kutub wal-Dirasat Al-Arabiyya, Alexandria, 2018.

Mazen Lilo Radi, Protecting Legal Security in Contemporary Legal Systems, First Edition, Arab Center, Cairo, 2020.

Mohammed Bahi Abu Younis, The Penalty of Threatening, Third Edition, Dar Al-Jamia Al-Jadida for Publishing, Alexandria, Egypt, 2001.

Wissam Sabbar Al-Ani, Administrative Judiciary, First Edition, Dar Al-Sanhouri, Baghdad, 2015.

Third: Theses University

Ahmed Sabah Hussein, The Phenomenon of the Lebanese Administration's Non-Compliance in Implementing Decisions Issued Against It by the Administrative Judiciary, Master's Thesis, Islamic University of Lebanon, Faculty of Law, 2021.

Ali Mahmoud Aliq, Problems of Implementing Administrative Court Rulings, Master's Thesis, Islamic University of Lebanon, Faculty of Law, 2015.

Aziz Hajira, The Public Administration's Refusal to Implement Administrative Court Rulings, Master's Thesis, Mouloud Mammeri University, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Algeria, 2018.

Issam Hatem Hussein, Means of Compelling the Administration to Implement Court Rulings, Master's Thesis, Al-Mustansiriya University, Faculty of Law, 2012.

Kamal Eddine Rais, Mechanisms for Obligating the Administration to Implement Administrative Court Rulings in the Administrative and Civil Procedures Law, Master's Thesis, Arab Ben M'hidi University - Oum El Bouaghi, Faculty of Law, Algeria, 2014.

Ramadan Farid, Implementing Administrative Court Rulings and Its Problems for the Administration, Master's Thesis, University of Batna, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Algeria. 2014.

Ziad Khalaf Awda, The Administration's Obligation to Implement Administrative Court Rulings, PhD Thesis, Al-Nahrain University, Faculty of Law, 2015.

Fourth: Research

Ahmed Mahmoud Al-Rubaie and Zahraa Hisham Al-Qazzaz, The Legal System of Financial Credit, A Comparative Study, a study published in the Maysan Journal of Comparative Legal Studies, Issue 9, Volume 1, 2023.

Dana Abdul Karim Saeed, The Role of the Administrative Judiciary in Establishing the Principle of Legal Security, a study published in the Scientific Journal of Cihan University, Sulaimani, Volume 4, Issue 2, 2020.

Ahmed Qasim Ali, the legal system of the employee's duty to be conservative in his general behavior, a comparative study, research published in Maysan Journal of Comparative Legal Studies, Volume 1, Issue 2, 2020.

Faisal Shatnawi, "Administrative Judicial Rulings Issued Against the Administration and Implementation Problems," a study published in the Journal of Sharia and Law Sciences, Volume 43, Supplement 1, Jordan, 2016.

Rusul Saadoun Hussein, The Role of Public Administration in Achieving the Objectives of Criminal Sanctions, a Comparative Study, Research Published in Maysan Journal of Comparative Legal Studies, Volume 1, Issue 2, 2020.

Hamza Jassim Muhammad, "Administrative Refusal to Implement Administrative Judicial Rulings," Iraqi University Journal, Issue 61, Vol. 1, 2023.

Mazen Lilo Radi, Means of Implementing Administrative Judiciary Rulings, Journal of Law, College of Law, Al-Mustansiriya University, Volume 12, Issue 12, 2018.

Muhammad Jamal Zain, The Difference in the Implementation of Employment Contracts between Impossibility and Exhaustion and Their Determinants in Light of the Coronavirus Pandemic, Journal of the College of Law for Legal and Political Sciences, Volume 9, Issue (Special), 2020.

Fifth: Legislation

Iraqi Evidence Law No. 107 of 1979, as amended.

Sixth: Judicial Decisions

Decision No. 79 of 12/16/2007, Collection of Decisions and Fatwas of the Council of State for the year 2007, Ministry of Justice, Council of State.